Special Reports > Cannes Lions 08

Penney CMO: Saatchi's Response OK

Applauds agency's actions following Cannes commercial controversy

July 3, 2008

-By Andrew McMains


adweek/photos/stylus/31990-MikeBoylson.jpg

Mike Boylson

NEW YORK JC Penney chief marketing officer Mike Boylson said today that he was satisfied with lead creative agency Saatchi & Saatchi's response to the "Speed Dressing" fracas at the Cannes International Advertising Festival last month.

Publicis Groupe's Saatchi apologized for the content of the ad, for which production company Epoch Films won a bronze Lion. The spot depicted a teenage girl and boy practicing how fast they can dress before meeting up at the girl's house -- presumably to fool around downstairs -- without getting caught by the girl's mom.

Epoch submitted the execution as a TV spot for Penney, but the client said it never approved the concept and it never ran. Furthermore, Penney objected to the ad's message of promiscuity. After the outcry, Epoch withdrew its submission, thereby forfeiting its Lion.

Saatchi maintained that it had nothing to do with the entry, but nonetheless said it deeply regretted the message that the ad conveyed.

And although Saatchi blamed Epoch and director Michael Long for producing and submitting the spot, the New York agency also reimbursed Penney for the likely cost of production, Boylson told Adweek. Typically, agencies hire production companies and later bill clients for the work.

Boylson said: "The thing that bothered me was: 1.) [Epoch] used our name and our brand; 2.) They used our brand positioning, 'Every day matters'; and 3.) Whether they admit it or not -- we paid for the production. So, I'm still convinced [that] somehow that got billed back to us. So we worked with Saatchi & Saatchi, came up with an agreed-upon number that we thought the production value was [and] they've reimbursed us for that."

Boylson declined to name a figure. "It wasn't a huge number, but it was enough to satisfy us that we were reimbursed," he added.

Reflecting on Saatchi's response, Boylson said agency executives were "terrific. They were very apologetic. They felt very bad about it."

He added that "most of the people at Saatchi & Saatchi didn't know it even happened until it was too late. So, what they were most disappointed about was they didn't catch it and didn't stop it."

He further described the Epoch episode as "water under the bridge" and "more a distraction than anything else," saying -- as he did two weeks ago -- that "certainly when you look at the agency -- our relationship with them is a lot bigger than this one issue."

CLICK HERE FOR MORE ABOUT THE CONTROVERSY.


Penney CMO: Saatchi's Response OK

Applauds agency's actions following Cannes commercial controversy

July 3, 2008

-By Andrew McMains


adweek/photos/stylus/31990-MikeBoylson.jpg

Mike Boylson

NEW YORK JC Penney chief marketing officer Mike Boylson said today that he was satisfied with lead creative agency Saatchi & Saatchi's response to the "Speed Dressing" fracas at the Cannes International Advertising Festival last month.

Publicis Groupe's Saatchi apologized for the content of the ad, for which production company Epoch Films won a bronze Lion. The spot depicted a teenage girl and boy practicing how fast they can dress before meeting up at the girl's house -- presumably to fool around downstairs -- without getting caught by the girl's mom.

Epoch submitted the execution as a TV spot for Penney, but the client said it never approved the concept and it never ran. Furthermore, Penney objected to the ad's message of promiscuity. After the outcry, Epoch withdrew its submission, thereby forfeiting its Lion.

Saatchi maintained that it had nothing to do with the entry, but nonetheless said it deeply regretted the message that the ad conveyed.

And although Saatchi blamed Epoch and director Michael Long for producing and submitting the spot, the New York agency also reimbursed Penney for the likely cost of production, Boylson told Adweek. Typically, agencies hire production companies and later bill clients for the work.

Boylson said: "The thing that bothered me was: 1.) [Epoch] used our name and our brand; 2.) They used our brand positioning, 'Every day matters'; and 3.) Whether they admit it or not -- we paid for the production. So, I'm still convinced [that] somehow that got billed back to us. So we worked with Saatchi & Saatchi, came up with an agreed-upon number that we thought the production value was [and] they've reimbursed us for that."

Boylson declined to name a figure. "It wasn't a huge number, but it was enough to satisfy us that we were reimbursed," he added.

Reflecting on Saatchi's response, Boylson said agency executives were "terrific. They were very apologetic. They felt very bad about it."

He added that "most of the people at Saatchi & Saatchi didn't know it even happened until it was too late. So, what they were most disappointed about was they didn't catch it and didn't stop it."

He further described the Epoch episode as "water under the bridge" and "more a distraction than anything else," saying -- as he did two weeks ago -- that "certainly when you look at the agency -- our relationship with them is a lot bigger than this one issue."

CLICK HERE FOR MORE ABOUT THE CONTROVERSY.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author:
* Comment:
 

Other Cannes Lions 08

p

Unlucky Penney: Epoch Caught With Its Pants Down

June 30, 2008

NEW YORK The flap surrounding the spot in the name of JC Penney that won a bronze Lion at Cannes, only to be withdrawn after Penney said it never approved the ad and it never aired, brought to the fore the problem of speculative or scam ads being submitted to awards shows. And although some suggested, for example, that the International Advertising Festival create a new category for spec work, it's clear that there's no easy answer to something that's been going on for a long time. Read Full Article



Our ProductsOur Products

ADWEEK'S NIGHTLY NEWS

Receive a comprehensive roundup of the biggest stories of the day.

BREAKING NEWS ALERTS

Sign up to be the first to hear about the biggest breaking news stories.

SUBSCRIBE

Stay connected to what's happening in the advertising industry with delivery of the print edition and complete online access.

More VideosVideo

Clydesdale Kiss; Video player for AW Special Reports index and related pages. http://link.brightcove.com/services/link/bcpid1328265983http://www.brightcove.com/channel.jsp?channel=1126101268






Nick Law, Titanium Lions juror

Sunday, June 22, 2008 - Well, that's it then. The 55th orgy of advertising. Record attendances, a s...

Visit LeFreaque







From print to online advertising trends, advertising professionals can read all about the latest advertising news at Adweek. Keep on top of the latest happenings in the advertising world, from online video advertising to the latest funny TV commercials. Check out our community and advertiser forums to discover and network with other advertiser and marketing professionals. Adweek provides advertisers with daily TV news and weekly ad industry editorials on a complete array of subjects. Use our advertising agency directory to find a career opportunity or to research an ad agency to fit your companies advertising and marketing needs. Explore Adweek everyday, or sign up for our Adverting Newsletter to get the latest ad industry news on demand!

Adweek Advertising Home | Advertising Industry News | Creative TV Advertising | Advertising Industry Community | Video Advertising | Advertising Data Center | Advertising Special Reports | Advertising Careers | Advertising Products | Advertising About Us | Advertising Business Statements | Advertising Contact Us | Advertising Opportunities | Ad Licensing | Advertiser FAQ | Advertising Magazine Subscriptions | Advertising News RSS | Online Ad Site Map | Mobile

© 2008 Nielsen Business Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Terms of Use  |   Privacy Policy